top of page

FCA Claims Handling Review: What Home and Travel Insurers Need to Fix

Writer: Andrew Arginovski
Andrew Arginovski
2 hours ago
8 min read
Insurance claims handler reviewing a home insurance claim file at a desk

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has found that some home and travel insurers may not be meeting their obligations under the Consumer Duty when customers make a claim. Its review of home and travel claims handling arrangements, published on 22 July 2025, identified weak oversight of outsourced claims handlers, poor management information (MI), low payout rates on storm claims and inadequate control of cash settlements. Insurers can outsource claims activity, but the FCA is clear that they cannot outsource their regulatory responsibilities.


The FCA reviewed 15 home insurance providers and 8 travel insurance providers and has since taken follow-up action with individual firms. More than a year on, the findings remain the clearest statement of what the FCA expects to see in a claims function, and they are relevant to any insurer, managing general agent (MGA) or claims handler acting under delegated authority that has not yet tested its arrangements against them.


What Did the FCA Review?


The FCA carried out the work in response to intelligence pointing to poor claims handling practices. Home and travel were chosen because, after motor, they are the most commonly held insurance products. Value measures data reported to the FCA showed over 2.5 million home claims and over 1.5 million travel claims between 2022 and 2024, with more than £9 billion paid to customers.


The sample was broadly representative and deliberately included firms that outsourced significant parts of their claims handling, UK branches of overseas insurers and firms serving the UK from abroad. Claims file testing focused on complex and higher-value claims: home buildings and contents claims on private residential dwellings, and travel medical emergency, repatriation and cancellation claims. The FCA notes that its findings are not a comprehensive or representative overview of travel claims handling.


The FCA organised its findings into four areas:

  1. Insurers' oversight of outsourced claims handling providers.

  2. Availability and use of MI.

  3. Claims handling arrangements, including storm claims and cash settlements.

  4. Claims governance.


It is important to be clear about the status of this publication. It does not introduce new rules. It sets out FCA findings, examples of good and poor practice and supervisory expectations against existing requirements, principally the Consumer Duty, the FCA's outsourcing and systems and controls requirements, and the product governance rules in PROD 4.


The FCA's Key Findings


Outsourced Claims Handling Lacked Effective Oversight


Every insurer in the sample outsourced some part of its claims handling, from first notification of loss through to the entire process, whether to third parties or within the group. The FCA found that 5 insurers, all of which substantially outsourced their claims operations, had limited control over those arrangements or material weaknesses in oversight. Three were UK branches of overseas firms and one served the UK from overseas.


Six of the 23 firms had no documented oversight framework, and the FCA saw poor outcomes in those firms, including high upheld complaint volumes and long settlement times. Among the firms that did have frameworks, design and effectiveness varied considerably.


The firms that performed better used a combination of tools: quality assurance checks, customer journey testing, claims sample testing, audits, structured and minuted meetings, and granular conduct MI from the outsourced provider. The FCA observed that these firms were more likely to identify problems with third parties and act on them. Intra-group arrangements should be overseen as if they were outsourced to an external third party.


Management Information Did Not Show Customer Outcomes


The FCA saw wide variation in the quality, breadth and use of claims MI. Board MI was in some cases limited in detail and weighted towards financial performance, so it did not surface customer outcome issues. MI produced only at product level masked emerging problems, and some MI lacked the narrative needed to identify root causes.


Tolerances were a particular weakness. Only 11 of the 23 firms could evidence appropriately set tolerances that were subject to review, and 12 firms had shortcomings in how they set them. The FCA's examples are instructive for any firm reviewing its own MI pack:

  • metrics with no tolerances at all;

  • RAG ratings with thresholds set too low, giving false assurance;

  • thresholds copied from market benchmarks without considering whether they suited the firm's products and customers; and

  • risk ratings left to an individual's judgement rather than defined tolerances.


On vulnerability, 11 of the 23 firms lacked adequate MI on outcomes for vulnerable customers, including 2 with no specific monitoring at all. Some firms identified vulnerable customers but did not flag them on claims systems, leaving them exposed to poor outcomes.


Claims Service Failures, Especially in Travel


Most firms had claims policies intended to support good outcomes, and 18 of the 23 had a written claims strategy. In practice, the FCA found too many customers not receiving the service they were entitled to. Over a quarter of firms upheld a high proportion of service-related complaints, with some uphold rates above 70%, and the most extreme examples were often in firms that materially outsourced claims handling.


The FCA's concerns were sharper for travel insurance, where claims are often made in emergencies and the customer may be unwell abroad. It saw examples of limited support, failed or delayed repatriation and unclear or misleading communications.


Storm Claims: Only 32% Resulted in a Payment


This is the finding that attracted most attention. Of 118,890 claims classified as storm claims by the sampled firms in 2024, only 32% resulted in a settlement payment, 49% were rejected and 19% of customers did not continue with the claim. Common reasons for rejection were wear and tear or lack of maintenance, damage below the excess, and weather not meeting the insurer's definition of a storm.


The FCA accepted that most rejected claims had valid reasons under the policy terms. Its concern is that the pattern points to poor customer understanding of the cover, which raises questions under the consumer understanding outcome and under PROD 4 about whether products have been designed and tested for their target market. The FCA reviewed over 50 policy wordings and found that 8 had no storm definition and 11 used their own definitions, some of which created ambiguity. It also found firms relying on weather data without considering contributory factors, and one firm where claims notified online were more likely to be rejected than those notified by telephone.


Cash Settlements Used Without Adequate Controls


Eleven of the 15 home insurers had a clear, documented approach to cash settlements. However, 4 had no criteria for deciding when a cash settlement was appropriate, 4 did not appear to consider vulnerability, and 5 carried out little or no monitoring. Some firms had no staff authority limits on cash settlement values. The FCA was concerned that some firms may be choosing cash settlements mainly to contain costs, and noted legal risks where settlements reflect supplier discounts that are not available to the customer.


Governance Records Did Not Evidence Challenge


Governance structures were broadly appropriate in 21 of the 23 firms. The weakness was evidence. Committee minutes often lacked enough detail to show meaningful discussion, challenge or decision-making, and senior managers attending forums did not always leave a record of their engagement. Two firms had not allocated responsibility for claims handling to a senior management function (SMF) holder, and where SMF responsibility existed, it was not always reflected in the statement of responsibilities.


Key Themes for Insurers and Delegated Authority Firms


Three messages run through the review. First, documentation is not the same as control: the FCA repeatedly found frameworks in place but not working consistently. Second, MI is the mechanism that connects outsourcing, vulnerability, governance and outcomes; where MI was weak, every other control was weakened with it. Third, firms were often slow to act on issues they had already identified, which the FCA regards as ongoing customer harm.


What Has Happened Since the Review?


The FCA said it would give individual feedback to all firms in the review and asked trade bodies to consider further action on storm claims by winter 2025. In its response to the Which? super-complaint in December 2025, the FCA reported opening enforcement investigations, commissioning skilled person reviews and asking 13 of the 15 home insurers to review their handling of storm claims and/or cash settlements. It also said it would extend its outsourcing work to delegated authority models from 2026 and update the market on its actions before the end of 2026. Firms should therefore expect continued scrutiny of claims outcomes, not a closed review.


What Should Firms Do Now


The starting point is to establish how far the findings apply. An insurer that writes home or travel business is directly within scope; an MGA, broker or administrator handling claims under delegated authority should expect its capacity providers to apply these expectations to it. Firms writing other general insurance lines will also find the review a useful benchmark. Most firms will not need a new framework. A targeted review against the FCA's findings will usually be the proportionate response.


We would suggest firms consider the following steps:

  • Test outsourcing oversight against the FCA's good practice tools, confirming that MI is received consistently from every claims handler and that intra-group arrangements are overseen as if external.

  • Review the claims MI pack to check that it covers customer outcomes as well as financial performance, includes narrative and root cause analysis, and is broken down below product level.

  • Check that every key metric has a documented tolerance with a clear rationale, and that RAG thresholds would trigger action rather than give false assurance.

  • Confirm that vulnerable customers are identified, flagged on claims systems and tracked through to outcome.

  • For home insurers, review storm definitions, wear and tear wording and how this information is presented, and analyse storm rejection and walkaway rates by notification channel.

  • Set criteria, authority limits and monitoring for cash settlements, including when they should not be offered.

  • Confirm that an SMF holder is responsible for claims, that this appears in the statement of responsibilities, and that committee minutes record challenge and decisions.


Finally, document the review and its conclusions. If the FCA asks how the firm responded to the review, a dated gap analysis with owners and actions is far more persuasive than an assurance that arrangements were considered.


Frequently Asked Questions


What did the FCA's home and travel claims handling review find?


The FCA found examples of good practice but many areas for improvement across 23 insurers. The main weaknesses were poor oversight of outsourced claims handlers, inadequate MI and tolerances, low payout rates on storm claims, weak control of cash settlements, and governance records that did not show effective challenge.


Does the review introduce new FCA rules?


No. It is a good and poor practice publication. It sets out the FCA's findings and expectations against existing requirements, including the Consumer Duty, outsourcing and systems and controls requirements, and the product governance rules in PROD 4.


Why did so few storm claims result in a payment?


The FCA found that only 32% of storm claims made to the sampled firms in 2024 resulted in a payment. Most rejections were valid under policy terms, but the FCA linked the pattern to poor customer understanding of storm definitions and wear and tear exclusions.


Can an insurer outsource responsibility for claims handling?


No. The FCA states that firms may outsource elements of claims handling but cannot outsource their regulatory responsibilities. Insurers must supervise outsourced activity and ensure third parties deliver outcomes consistent with those delivered in-house.


Are cash settlements allowed under the Consumer Duty?


Yes, cash settlement can be appropriate. The FCA expects firms to have criteria for when it is suitable, to consider customer vulnerability, to set authority limits and to monitor outcomes, and not to use cash settlements mainly to contain costs.


How Compliance Angle Can Help


Compliance Angle supports insurers, MGAs and insurance intermediaries in reviewing their claims arrangements against the FCA's expectations. Our support is practical and proportionate, reflecting each firm's business model, permissions, size and regulatory risk.


Relevant support includes:


If you would like to discuss how the review applies to your firm, please contact us at info@complianceangle.co.uk.


Source: Financial Conduct Authority, "Home and travel claims handling arrangements: good practice and areas for improvement", published 22 July 2025.

bottom of page